Erstwhile Strokes vocalist Julian Casablancas made a few headlines, recently, when he confessed to British newspaper, The Guardian, that a certain song he wrote, decades ago, namely his band’s arguable signature single, “Last Nite,” was “pretty dead” to him. He claimed to not be sure why, but I’d wager the weary task of having to perform it conceivably each and every time the Strokes take the stage might have something to do with it. I’d imagine other famous bands are equally bored to speechlessness with their own most well-known songs --- I can’t fathom how U2 gets up and plays “I Will Follow,” Pride (In the Name of Love)” and/or “With or Without You” with any semblance of sincerity, after all these years.
This heretically candid declaration came via a regular feature in The Guardian that, until recently, I was unaware of called “Honest Playlist.” For several years now, The Guardian has been putting a series of music-based questions by a wide array of public figures – I didn’t know most of them, if I’m being honest, but other familiar faces did pop up, like Jon Bon Jovi, Perry Farrell, John Cooper Clarke, George Benson, Elvis Costello and …er… William Shatner. I wouldn’t say I’m in the same league as any of those individuals but considering some of the C-Listers they did pose these questions to, I figured I’d take a stab at the “Honest Playlist” questionnaire, too.
So here goes…
The first song I remember hearing: There was a fair amount of music in our house, growing up, both by way of my mother and stepfather, but also my actual father (divorced from my mother upon the happy occasion of my birth) and my grandparents. As such, I have memories of hearing records by artists like The Beatles, Carole King, Judy Collins, Cat Stevens, The Partridge Family, Stan Getz, Dave Brubeck, Abba, Simon & Garfunkel, Harry Belafonte and a ton of classical stuff. But if I had to pinpoint a specific song that I remember from way back, I’d have to say it was probably “Love Will Keep Us Together” by The Captain & Tennille from about 1975, when I’d have been about 7 or 8 years old.
The first song I fell in love with: From that very same era, I remember routinely hearing C.W. McCall’s “Convoy” from the back seat of my dad’s car during long drives to his weekend house in Columbia County, NY, and always hoping he or my stepmother wouldn’t change the station. I don’t know why I loved it, as a sniveling 7-year-old, and I’m fairly certain I didn’t even know what a convoy was, but I remember loving it, for some reason. When I hear it now, I can’t say I still harbor any affinity for it at all. It’s insufferable.
The first record I owned: I remember being given the original soundtrack recording of Disney’s “Dumbo,” as a child, but I’m not sure that’s what this question is searching for. The first record I voluntarily owned and bought with my own, dubiously earned allowance was Dressed to Kill by KISS. I still own it and still play it.
The first single I bought: I think the first vinyl 45 I ever bought was “Another Brick in the Wall Pt. II” by Pink Floyd, picked up at the Lexington Avenue Disc-O-Mat on East 58th Street. I sprang for the full, double-LP of The Wall shortly after that.
The performance that I’ll never forget: I’ve spun this yarn before, but in October of 1978, I was with my family at my step-uncle’s big house up in the Berkshires, and because I was there with all my cool, older cousins, I was allowed to stay up and watch “Saturday Night Live,” which – at the time – was still a very big deal. I’d have been about 11 years old, by this point, so staying awake past midnight was kind of huge. In any case, the host was comedian Fred Willard and, at some point after a few sketches and maybe a “Mr. Bill” film, he introduced the musical guest. Suddenly, DEVO appears in their yellow suits and the room falls absolutely silent as they launch into their cover of “Satisfaction.” I remember looking around at my cousins and no one was quite sure whether they were a real band or just another surreal sketch. I was immediately intrigued.
The song that changed my life: It’s a bit of a predictable one, for me, at this point, but I’d have to say “Eighties” by Killing Joke, which I first heard in the Greenwich Village apartment of the father of my friend Spike (not his actual name, but indicative of his temperament and immortalized here). We were watching some cable channel (not MTV) in the Spring of 1984, and the video came on. When it finished, I walked right out the door and across Cornelia Street to Subterranean Records and bought the 12” single of same on the spot.
The best song to play at a party: I’d imagine it would depend on who’s attending, but I’d have to say the best results I ever prompted when commandeering a party’s sound system were with “My Name is Prince” by --- WAIT FOR IT -- Prince, which injected a swiftly fading and flailing New Year’s Eve party I attended in the early `90s with a weapons-grade dosage of libidinous abandon.
The song that makes me cry: I used to cite “This Woman’s Work” by Kate Bush for this type of question, and it still does indeed do the trick, especially the way Kate sings “oh darlin’, make it go away!” In more recent years, however, I heard “Damage” by David Sylvian and Robert Fripp, which also is a bit of a heart-stabber.
The song I’ve streamed the most: I’m sure there’s a way to determine this on Spotify, but I just don’t know how to do that. I don’t imagine that the answer would be that much of a surprising revelation.
The song I’m listening to right now: Apparently, the last song I was listening to last night during my commute home from work was “Feel So Sad” (Rhapsodies Mix) by Spirtualized. Try not to read too deeply into that.
The song I wish I had written: Well, I’m not a songwriter, so I don’t regularly have those sorts of thoughts. I suppose I wish I’d written something that is both universally beloved and maddeningly overplayed, as this would presumably earn me a sizable amount of royalties, although not nearly as much as it might have once done, given the ever-shifting topography of quantifying what songwriters are entitled to in the age of streaming.
The best song to have sex to: I would disclose the selection that was playing when I first crossed this majestic Rubicon, but I’m afraid that would out me as the shamefully late-bloomer that I was. Moreover, as momentous (for me) as that occasion was, it was not entirely indicative of the ideal scenario for such an activity, so that’s enough about that. I think the best music to score this particular act is something suitably languid but nothing too obtrusive, so maybe something atmospheric like This Mortal Coil or latter era Talk Talk, although certain records by both of those names do frequently plunge headlong into the unexpectedly melancholy, and no one is well served by that. You also don’t want to completely overthink it and throw on something preposterously pretentious like Erik Satie’s Gymnopedies or Glen Gould’s take on Bach’s Goldberg Variations. I mean, those are great pieces of music but get ahold of yourself. I can think of some jazz records that might also do the trick, but those can go well off the rails, too. I’d suggest comparing notes with your partner and seeing what strikes their mood. As long as it’s not Limp Bizkit or the Banana Splits’ theme song, I’m sure you’ll be fine.
The song I can no longer listen to: It’s not really that I can no longer listen to it, as I think it still completely holds up, musically, and sounds as great as it did upon my first hearing of it, but “Peace Sells” by Megadeth. While Megadeth were never my go-to band of the so-called “Big Four,” they did have their moments, and “Peace Sells” was certainly one of them, along with other cuts like “Wake Up Dead” and “Symphony of Destruction.” I thought their cover of “Anarchy in the UK” was abysmal, but whatever. In any case, back in 2012, Megadeth lead singer/songwriter Dave Mustaine asserted that certain mass shootings of the era like Aurora and the Sihk Temple massacre had been orchestrated by the Obama administration to ramp up gun control. Once I heard that crazy, objectionable bullshit, I lost all interest in ever giving any of my time to Megadeth ever again and have never really looked back.
The last song I streamed: Let me look. Evidently, this morning, it was “Brighter,” which is track from the first Slowdive album.
The song I can’t stand: Just one? There are countless songs that I cannot stand. For this exercise, however, I’ll go with “Empire State of Mind” by Jay-Z and Alicia Keys. That “concrete jungle where dreams are made of” bullshit never ceases to set my teeth on edge. It’s also neck-snappingly trite. Fuck everything about that crap.
The song I have to get up to turn off: “American Pie” by Don McLean. I will very happily get up to turn it right the fuck off or promptly leave any fucking room wherein this song is playing.
The song I’d want for my stadium entrance music: Jerry Goldsmith’s opening theme to the 1975 epic, “The Wind & the Lion,” starring Sean Connery and Candace Bergen.
The best song for my mental health: “I Will Refuse” by Pailhead.
The song I do at karaoke: Despite being what some might consider unduly preoccupied with music, it might be surprising to some to learn that I fucking hate karaoke. I don’t like doing it, I don’t like watching (or, more specifically, hearing it), I don’t think it’s fun and any time it’s invoked as some sort of option, I usually go well out of my way to try to excise myself from proceedings. That doesn’t always work, and there have been a few occasions wherein I was obligated to, but rest assured that no matter how many beers I might have consumed along the way, I did not enjoy it. It’s just not for me, … ever.
Why is this, you ask? Well, for a start, I simply don’t enjoy hearing people butchering my favorite music. Hell, I don’t even enjoy hearing people warble tunelessly through songs I don’t like. Some people, in my opinion, are simply not meant to have a microphone at their mouths. To be fair, I firmly consider myself to be one of these people. No one benefits from hearing me sing, even for drunkenly comedic reasons. It’s not one of my gifts, and I doubt anyone would disagree on that front.
Then, of course, there’s the frequent nightmare of being stuck in one of those invariably claustrophobic little rooms with someone who genuinely thinks that they can and should be singing. I frankly don’t know which is the worst scenario – hearing someone hoarsely holler the lyrics to LMFAO’s “Party Rockin’” or listening to someone earnestly interpret Whitney Houston’s “Greatest Love of All” as if they’re auditioning for Broadway. No amount of beer can salvage that experience.
As expressed above, I do sincerely hate hearing a favorite song of mine sullied not only by the pointedly unskilled vocal cords of a fellow party goer but by the indignity of karaoke-association alone. One of the last times I was dragged to karaoke, I remember wincing when the wife of a friend of mine insisted on trying her hand at “Young Americans” by David Bowie. While never a favorite track of mine by the late icon, it surely deserved a better fate than that. I did take some solace when the song revealed itself to be pronouncedly more lyrically complicated than she’d anticipated, finding her sheepishly giggling her way through Bowie’s more oblique wordplay.
But, to answer the question, the tracks I’ve managed to get through are “Maneater” by Hall & Oates and Soft Cell’s rendition of “Tainted Love.”
The song I inexplicably know every lyric to: I inexplicably know the lyrics to hundreds of songs because one could credibly argue that I am unhealthily overinvested in my appreciation of music. It takes up space in my brain that would otherwise be better utilized with, say, knowing how to cook competently or being able to do my own taxes. But, to answer the question, once again, my friend Jay had a band in college called The Janitors of Anarchy, and whenever they played certain off-campus houses, I was invited along to sing (usually inaudibly, thankfully … drowned out by the band). I was only invited to assume the mic during “She Sells Sanctuary” by The Cult, if only because I was the only one who accurately knew the lyrics.
The song that I secretly like, but tell people I hate: I don’t know that this really applies, as I don’t believe I am all that secretive about my likes and dislikes, nor do I feel any concerns about being judged over my listening habits. I like precisely what I like, and too bad for you if you think I shouldn’t.
The song I can no longer listen to: There used to be specific songs that I associated with certain eras of my life, and I figured that they’d maintain their resonance for the rest of my days. But while they may be indelibly marked, to my mind, by those associations, I frequently find that I’m completely still able to listen to them without plunging into an impenetrable thicket of melancholia. That either means that distance and time have scrubbed the song of those entanglements or that I’ve simply gotten over whatever that crucial episode was. There are certainly songs I never need to hear again – usually hoary warhorses like “Smells like Teen Spirit” or stuff of that ilk. I was never a huge fan of it to begin with, but oversaturation has robbed me of any desire to ever hear it again.
The song I’d like played in my funeral I suppose I’m supposed to say something typical here like “Requiem” by Killing Joke or “Everybody Loves You (When You’re Dead)” by Cop Shoot Cop, but I doubt I’d opt for either of those (as if I could do anything about it, anyway).
I'll leave it for someone else to pick that out.
Recent Comments