The figurative scales that represent my love/hate relationship with U2 dipped squarely into the "love" area recently upon finally hearing their cover (with Green Day) of "The Saints are Coming" by ye olde Skids. Yeah, I'm a bit late to the table on this (being that it's kinda old news by now), but I managed to lay ears on it this morning, courtesy of a copy of U2's entirely needless new compilation album, U218 Singles. Despite being maddeningly ubiquotous blowhards (well, Bono, anyway), I have to applaud U2 this time for getting it right. And by getting it right, I'm not so much suggesting their tireless altruism (proceeds from the sale of the single are going to aid Musicians Rising, an organization that replaces instruments lost by musicians in the wake of Hurricane Katrina), but rather by not taking a giant, runny dump on the song they were covering, as they did with, say, "Helter Skelter" -- though, honestly, no cover version has ever done that particular track justice, not even Siouxsie's. There's no reason why any of the surviving Skids should hear this single and wince.
Critics are likely to credit Green Day (the arguably "punker" of the two ensembles) with retaining the urgent fire of the Skids' original track from 1978, but it's U2 who are likely to have suggested this song sooner than Billy Joe Armstrong et al. (whose punk roots owe more to the likes of Operation Ivy than to the fabled Class of `77). The Skids came high-stepping out of Scotland as progenitors of huge, chant-laden anthems buoyed by big-ass guitars that owed precious little if anything to the spittle-drenched nihilism of their British Punk peers. Sadly little more than a footnote today (the band is usually simply name-checked as the outfit guitarist Stuart Adamson was in prior to forming Big Country and making his instrument sound like a bagpipe), the Skids caved in under the aspirations of singer, Richard Jobson (who formed the equally ambitious-if-slightly-darker Armoury Show -- featuring guitarist John McGeoch, later of Magazine, Siouxsie & the Banshees and Public Image Ltd.) who is evidently a television broadcaster these days. Stuart Adamson, meanwhile, sadly took his own life in 2001 after a long battle with alcoholism. No idea what became of the rest of the band.
In any case, you can clearly hear the Skids' influence on those early U2 records (especially on the chiming chug of "I Will Follow"). Never truly orthodox punk themselves (much like U2, despite all their shout-outs to being forged by a love for the Ramones and the Clash), the Skids' predeliction for hoarily heartfelt anthems rife with cinematic guitar fireworks helped set a veritable template for U2, so it seems only just that U2 should repay the band. The end results are surprisingly faithful and punchy in a manner U2 haven't sounded in years (I'm guessing the added youthful jolt supplied by Green Day played a large hand in that). Should you enjoy the single, I heartily endorse picking up the original (the cut-price compilation, Sweet Suburbia - the Best of the Skids, shouldn't be very hard to find). And while "The Saints are Coming" is indeed a rousing little number, I still say it pales in comparison to "Into the Valley" (not least for its earnest, non-ironic chants of "AHOY!" and impenetrable lyrics about being punctured and impailed in battle). Anyway, despite the decision to debut the song at a football game (I guess it makes sense, but I hate the spot-welding of sports and music -- sue me), silly cowboy hats off to U2 and long live the Skids.
Recent Comments